Friday, January 4, 2008

Forthcoming clarifications on Summorum Pontificum

There has been much discussion of late at the blog of Fr. Z, which I check daily and highly recommend if you are interested in liturgical news, on a forthcoming clarification of the motu proprio, Summorum Pontificum. In addition to Associated Press releasing an excellent article on the topic (below), you may want to read through some blogposts I have listed at the bottom.

While some bishops have been helpful and supportive of priests celebrating the Traditional Latin Mass others have been less than supportive, if not going out of their way to make it difficult by way of "norms" and other tactics.

The TLM had required the permission of the diocesan bishop through an "indult" prior to Summorum Pontificum which went into effect September 14, 2007. In metro Detroit, St. Josaphat was granted this indult and had already been celebrating the Mass using the missal of 1962.

Vatican clarifying Latin Mass rules
By NICOLE WINFIELD
Associated Press Writer

VATICAN CITY --The Vatican has begun drafting a document to elaborate on Pope Benedict XVI's recent liberalization of the old Latin Mass because some bishops are either ignoring his move or misinterpreting it, Vatican officials said.

The Vatican's No. 2, Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, said in comments published Thursday that the Vatican would be issuing an "instruction" on how to put the pope's document into practice, since there had been what he called some "uneven" reactions to it since it went into effect last year.

The document Benedict issued in July removed restrictions on celebrating the so-called Tridentine Mass, the rite celebrated in Latin before the liberalizing reforms of the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s paved the way for the new Mass used widely today in local languages.

Following the 1960s reform, the Tridentine rite could only be celebrated with permission from local bishops - an obstacle that supporters of the old rite said had greatly reduced its availability.

In a gesture to such traditional Catholics, Benedict removed that requirement in his document, saying parish priests could celebrate the Tridentine Mass if a "stable group of faithful" requested it.

Implementation, however, has been uneven, with some bishops issuing rules that "practically annul or twist the intention of the pope," Monsignor Albert Malcolm Ranjith, secretary of the Vatican's Congregation for the Divine Cult and Discipline of Sacraments, said recently, according to the Vatican's missionary news agency FIDES.

Such reactions amounted to a "crisis of obedience" toward the pontiff, he was quoted as saying, although he stressed that most bishops and other prelates had accepted the pope's will "with the required sense of reverence and obedience."

Bertone, the Vatican's secretary of state, said the upcoming instruction would lay out criteria for the pope's document to be correctly applied, according to an interview published Thursday in the Italian religious affairs weekly Famiglia Cristiana. He gave no date for its publication.

He complained that reactions to the pontiff's document had been uneven.

"Some have even gone so far as to accuse the pope of having reneged on Council teaching," Bertone was quoted as saying. "On the other hand, there are those who have interpreted the (document) as authorization to return exclusively to the pre-Council rite. Both positions are wrong, and are exaggerated episodes that don't correspond to the pope's intention."

Despite such incidents, the Rev. John T. Zuhlsdorf, who runs a blog that has charted implementation of the pope's document, said he had seen growth in both interest in and celebrations of the older form of the Mass.

"In some dioceses in the United States, bishops have been stepping up to the plate and not only learning the older form, but celebrating it themselves," he said in an e-mail. "Younger priests are attending workshops. Several seminaries are offering training for their priesthood candidates."

Even before the pope's document was released, liberal-minded Catholics had complained that Benedict's move amounted to a negation of Vatican II, and some bishops and cardinals publicly warned that its implementation would create a rupture in the church.

Jewish groups also complained because the old rite contains a Good Friday prayer for the conversion of Jews. Bertone has said the issue could be resolved and that the church in no way intended to go against its spirit of reconciling with Jews.

Benedict's document was also a bid to reach out to the followers of an excommunicated traditionalist, the late Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, who split with the Vatican over Council reforms, notably the introduction of the new Mass.


Since the release of the motu proprio, several parishes in metro Detroit are offering the so-called Tridentine Mass, including Assumption Grotto.

If someone wants to provide a list of other parishes in the area, please feel free to drop it in the combox. I can't recall all of them off hand, but the list does include St. Josaphat. I am aware that others will be offering it within the next few months, as well.

Related Documents and posts:






Te Deum Laudamus! Home

4 comments:

Jay3GSM said...

In our local Church there have been three masses said in Latin this week, and I have been fortunate enough to attend them all. I am not getting what the fuss is all about. I want to understand, but I don't see it. Maybe some readers of this blog can help?

I've been attending Mass for two years, and I gain full membership to the Church this Easter. I have a full respect for ALL teachings of the Church. I thought it was important to lay down my stance before hand.

Regarding the Latin Mass, I don't get why some people are so hung up on it all. Going to Mass is the single best thing I do, all week. The Mass in Latin is just not the same, and it isn't the language. I'm not fluent in Latin but I understand enough to know where in the Mass we are. Also I'm fluent in Italian, which helps a lot.

What is the attraction to the Latin Mass? Why does it appeal so much? Very often you can't even hear what the Priest is saying, as he whispers. I'm trying, and not very successfully, to get my questions over. If anyone thinks they have an idea of what I mean and can explain to me I'd love to read your thoughts on the subject. Thanks.

Diane K said...

Hi Jay,

First, my prayers for you as you pursue life as a Catholic.

I would love to discuss more on the questions you raise, perhaps in a post, rather than in a comment.

I must leave right now and would like to do so when I have a few minutes to address those things fully.

Check the homepage over the next day or two and I'll try to get to it.

God bless!

Oliver Hayes said...

It has been much reported that over here in England the bishops have been obstructive towards Summorum Pontificum, and that clarification is much needed. However in Birmingham Archdiocese where I live Archbishop Vincent Nichols has largely welcomed it, and as he was very generous with the indult in the past for us it has been very much business as usual.

AlexB said...

Prior to the Motu Proprio, the indult parishes in the area were St. Josaphat, Assumption-Windsor, and All Saints-Flint.

Post-MP, in addition to Grotto, we have St. Joseph-Detroit and St. Stephen-New Boston. Three others are in the final planning stages. Perhaps 3-5 additional ones will start by the end of 2008.