-April 18, 2010: Link to Ratzinger article on public/private revelations fixed
On April 15, 2010, Al Kresta of Ave Maria Radio and host of Kresta in the Afternoon, interviewed Catholic Apologist and radio show host Patrick Madrid (Medjugorje skeptic) and Rev. Neil Buchlein of West Virginia (priest who has visited 17 times since 2003). The subject.... you guessed it: Medjugorje.
Go listen to the audio at Pat's blog: Fr. Neil Buchlein and I discuss pros and cons of Medjugorje
- Al also has a thread for discussion on this
EDIT: April 17, 2010
Fr. Buchlein has a post up about this interview that is rather surprising in many ways (emphases mind in bold; comments bracketed in red).
This is the tape of yesterday afternoon's show. I was contacted yesterday afternoon and was asked if I would be available to answer some questions regarding Medjugorje and the Vatican Commission. I was very surprised to hear at 5PM when I tuned in that Patrick Madrid ( a very "open-minded skeptic" regarding Medjugorje) was also on the show. I was not told this by the station manager when I accepted the invitation [nor was Patrick told that Rev. Buchlein would be on the show. Al Kresta, being the fair-minded man that he is, allowed both sides to be presented]. Patrick has been very outspoken regarding Medjugorje and has a strong following. He prides himself in having read many books and articles about Medjugorje. Unfortunately he has never been there but I do hope that one day he may change his mind and and make a pilgrimmage and really see and experiece the "fruits." [Does one need to go to Bethlehem to believe Jesus was born? I lived in the Diocese of Mostar-Duvno from 1980 - 1983 and was discerning a vocation with the order of Franciscans responsible for the parish of St. James before it all happened in June of 1981. I saw good fruits. I turned skeptic in 2005 after not turning a blind-eye to bad fruits upon reading several documents from the diocese. I felt that the local bishop's objections were very reasonable, and this came after reading books by the chroniclers, Fr. Laurentin and Fr. Rupcic. Moving on...]. This would only happen if he were to be truly "open-minded" and leave his skepticism at home or at the bottom of apparition hill. I'm not sure if Patrick knows what the phrase "open-minded" really means but listen to the interview [Oh, Father - what disappointing thing to hear out of a priest]. If we ever do see the day when the apparitions of Medjugorje are fully approved I'll be interested in seeing if Patrick has been converted or if he will continue to wallow in his "open-mindedness" and I will continue to pray for him. [Converted? Converted to what? Is belief in "Our Lady of Medjugorje" required for salvation? Setting aside the condescending tone, is such a statement in harmony with the Catechism of the Catholic Church? What does the Church teach about private revelations? See below]In the interview, at one point, Fr. Buchlein acknowledges that you don't have to believe in Fatima or Lourdes, but he then obliges Patrick, in his blogpost above, to believe in Medjugorje if it is approved?
There is an excellent piece written by then Cardinal Ratzinger on the difference between public and private revelations and their theological status. In it, he makes clear:
- The authority of private revelations is essentially different from that of the definitive public Revelation
- Private revelation is a help to this faith, and shows its credibility precisely by leading me back to the definitive public Revelation.
- It is a help which is offered, but which one is not obliged to use. The criterion for the truth and value of a private revelation is therefore its orientation to Christ himself.
- Colin Donovan discusses CCC 66 and 67 on public and private revelation
- Colin Donovan on Medjugorje's status based on the 1991 Zadar Declaration (Note: This document is often cited by supporters for one or two statements, but many other things are overlooked. What he says in one area needs to be read in the context of the entire article)
- Revelations Public and Private by Jimmy Akin
- Video: Cardinal Arinze on Discerning Apparitions (@Patrick Madrid)
Te Deum Laudamus! Home
The obedient are not held captive by Holy Mother Church; it is the disobedient who are held captive by the world!